The Malaysian Insider :: Opinion
The Malaysian Insider :: Opinion |
| No quick fix for East Malaysia Posted: 02 Oct 2012 04:20 PM PDT OCT 3 ― "All you East Malaysians need to do is vote out BN!" I hear that time and time again from various people in Peninsular Malaysia and it's getting frankly tiresome. I apologise to Sarawakians in advance for having to explain things on your behalf, but I have lived in your state so am not totally clueless. Unlike the many who think that all that is needed is a Braveheart-like uprising where the united peoples of Sabah and Sarawak rise up against tyranny and all that jazz. It's not that simple. And that's my biggest beef with opposition rhetoric. It oversimplifies things, forgetting context and ignoring the complexities of East Malaysia. One challenge both Sabah and Sarawak have is geography. We're far removed from West Malaysia, quite literally, and in some ways it has worked out for the best but has also made integration tricky. There are far too many assumptions on each side about the other and "getting to know" each other requires a two- to three-hour flight. Sarawak is a huge state and its terrain makes traversing it prohibitively expensive. The Penans and other interior-dwelling folk have it worse; they are forced to trek hours to the nearest transport stop to get to the nearest city. They do not have ready access to the things we city dwellers take for granted: piped water, electronic and physical media, hospitals and decent schools. Even on the outskirts of Kota Kinabalu, the state capital of Sabah, there are schools that are little more than glorified shacks with crowded classrooms and malnourished children. Don't get me started on the West Malaysian teachers who refuse their postings to Sabah and Sarawak or clamour to be sent home as soon as possible. Racial tolerance is more pronounced here. Yet, the reality is that despite the "peace" between the various races in East Malaysia, it isn't easy to get them on the same page politically. Sabah, for instance, has various splinter parties that are also quite clearly delineated by race. SUPP is predominantly Chinese, PBS is mostly Sabah Bumiputera with a few Chinese people, the Muslim Bumiputeras once mostly congregated in USNO, but the BN-friendly now are in Umno. It's not much different in Sarawak. The various communities may get along better but dig down and their politics is the same old selfish Malaysian politics. It's never about what's best for the state or the country; it's about what's best for their own communities. Let the Penans rot in the jungles so long as my community gets first pick of lucrative contracts. That is the reality of the Malaysian mindset; the preoccupation with what's best for your own kind to the detriment of everyone else. Malaysians don't seem to believe in "win-win." It's "I take everything and everyone else can go die-lah." Which explains our love for monopolies. PKR's already shot itself in the foot by refusing to co-operate with local parties in Sabah and Sarawak. How am I, as a native from Sabah, supposed to place trust in a party that made Azmin Ali Sabah PKR chief? How am I supposed to believe that Anwar Ibrahim and his cohort won't do the same thing and just hand out division chief titles to people from the peninsula as "rewards" to the faithful once the state is won? What Pakatan Rakyat should be doing is forming alliances with local opposition parties. Instead, it intends to compete against them. Of course, BN will probably end up winning because of split votes. Don't get me started on people harping on about how Sarawakians should all unite and toss its current chief minister out. Here's news for you: The reason he's still in power is because the people who have benefitted from his position like him where he is. Ponder that for a moment. It took Bruno Manser to come in and unite the various Penan tribes. It will take more than a well-meaning Swiss to unite the various factions in the two states. Sadly the people trying to play catalyst are not altruistic crusaders but those with an eye on Putrajaya. By the way, because I have to keep reminding you, Sabah did vote against BN. But BN "convinced" PBS MPs to jump ship in the biggest "frog" incident in Malaysian history. Back in the day, Anwar Ibrahim was proud to be seen as "delivering" the state back to BN. It's not that simple; it was never that simple; it will never be that simple. So word of advice to Pakatan: When three words can sum up your campaign ("BN is bad!"), you need to do a lot better. * The views expressed here are the personal opinion of the columnist. |
| Posted: 02 Oct 2012 04:14 PM PDT OCT 3 ― After all the hoopla in the preceding weeks about the government's annual Budget, there is a strange feeling of it having been to all purposes a bit of a non-event. Even the near hysterical tone of the "spot on" theme of The Star's coverage of the Budget last year was replaced this time around by an almost factual tenor in the reporting of the Budget in the same newspaper. It's almost as if the prime minister was unable to either take the radical measures demanded by most economists or the equally radically populist measures demanded by his coalition given that that the general election is around the corner. It all came out a bit half hearted. Government revenue growth projections are almost flat, subsidies are largely intact, there are no real efforts to rein in the deficit except by hoping for better GDP growth next year, the GST was not even mentioned and corporate tax rates are unchanged. Clearly this was not a year for hard measures to either stimulate private investment or reduce government spending. On the other hand, even measures that would have been welcomed as lightening the middle-class burden such as lowering the individual income tax rates or increasing exemptions on income tax, substantially increasing the real property gains tax (RPGT) rates to curb speculation in the mid-level property market or even extending the cost of living allowance to the private sector have not come to fruition. In many ways, the continuation of the cash handouts to various groups betrays the BN's assumptions about the political maturity of Malaysian voters. They may not be wrong. After last year's BR1M handouts, the prime minister's popularity showed a marked uptick for a period of about three months. The political arithmetic seems to be that the average voter is so overwhelmed by gratitude in the face of a cash handout that a rise in popularity of the ruling coalition and consequently votes in the election immediately after are assured. But the problem with repeating handouts or bonuses to civil servants is the law of diminishing returns. In the case when these begin to be seen as commonplace, the level of gratitude is the obvious casualty. Even if the obvious irrelevance of such handouts in enhancing national productivity or welfare is ignored, big news measures such as reducing excise on cars or even abolishing the PTPTN would have had a much bigger impact on the government's popularity. In any case, this was the last real chance for the incumbent government before the elections to showcase statesmanship over politics, leadership over short-term populism and inclusivity over divisiveness. An opportunity it seems to have completely ignored. An opportunity to replace race-based politics with a needs and merit based approach, an opportunity to come down hard on institutionalised corruption and nepotism, an opportunity to shift government expenditure to a developmental agenda rather than one keeping an already bloated civil service happy, an opportunity to reform an education system where only the wealthy can access world class learning and an opportunity to promote gender equality over entrenched patriarchies. The cost of inaction on all these areas is a much larger story than the one on a Budget that ostensibly tried to please everyone but will genuinely please very few. In a world growing more competitive daily, narrow partisan agendas using race and religion intent on distracting Malaysians from the drastic measures required to move to a high income nation may prove ultimately suicidal, even for race and religion to thrive. If this Budget is actually seen by the rakyat as a panacea for all its ills and the government rewarded accordingly, then it is truly a nation very easily pleased, deserving of the policies it lives under. * The views expressed here are the personal opinion of the columnist. |
| You are subscribed to email updates from The Malaysian Insider :: Opinion To stop receiving these emails, you may unsubscribe now. | Email delivery powered by Google |
| Google Inc., 20 West Kinzie, Chicago IL USA 60610 | |
0 ulasan:
Catat Ulasan