April 13, 2013
Andy West is a sports writer originally from the UK and now living in Barcelona. He has worked in professional football since 1998 and specialises in the Spanish Primera Division and the English Premier League. Follow him on Twitter at @andywest01. |
APRIL 13 ― Earlier this week I went to watch Barcelona's most important game of the season ― their quarter final tie in Europe's elite club competition. And I can safely say it was one of the best atmospheres I've ever witnessed at a sporting event.
From the very start of the game, the majority of fans were up on the feet, shouting and singing, cheering every positive move made by their team and creating an intensely hostile environment for the visiting team and the poor old match officials.
In the tense and nervous closing stages, with both teams chasing victory, the decibel levels rose even higher, with a cacophony of whistles almost loud enough to split your eardrums every time the visitors moved anywhere near a scoring position.
But the vociferous backing of the fans was ultimately to no avail, because Panathinaikos withstood the barrage and came away with a crucial victory.
Panathinaikos? Yes, that's right. Did you think it was something else?
I'm talking about Euroleague basketball, and Panathinaikos sealing a dramatic one-point win in the Palau Blaugrana on Thursday night, levelling up the five-game quarter final series at one game apiece. They will now reconvene in Athens next week, with Pana having the chance to move into next month's Final Four weekend if they can claim a couple of home wins.
Of course, I could have also been talking about Barcelona's footballers, who progressed to the semi-finals of the Champions League thanks to a 1-1 draw with Paris St Germain on Wednesday night.
Except that nothing I said about the fans and the atmosphere during the basketball game could also apply to the previous evening at the Nou Camp, where 96,000 people spent most of the game sitting on their hands, waiting for their team to entertain them and score the goals they were expecting.
OK, I'm exaggerating. But only a little. The atmosphere at the Nou Camp on Wednesday night, even though it was such a crucial game with Barca's season on the line against a difficult opponent, was terrible (except the five minutes before and after Barca's equaliser, and the final few minutes of the game).
Less than fifteen minutes before kick-off, the stadium was half empty. When the players emerged from a tunnel, they were afforded a gentle, friendly but notably unimpassioned welcome more in keeping with a pre-season friendly. And when the game got underway, there were occasional outbreaks of gentle applause and modest chanting, but certainly little you would describe as fervent passionate backing. Certainly nothing compared to the support of the basketball fans the following night.
This is nothing new. Although visiting the Nou Camp is a wonderful experience for the sheer scale of the place and the splendour of the football, it's hardly a stadium renowned for its atmosphere. There are exceptions, of course: The noise levels rise considerably whenever Real Madrid roll into town, and there was electricity in the air for the thrilling Champions League victory over AC Milan in March.
But most of the time, the atmosphere is more akin to what you'd expect from a classical concert hall than the raucousness of a rock gig, and it's a problem that Barcelona are aware of and attempting to address, with club president Sandro Rosell getting himself into trouble a few weeks ago when he was accused of entering into a murky secret alliance with a group of particularly boisterous fans.
Barcelona are by no means the only major club whose fans struggle to generate a decent atmosphere on all but the very biggest of occasions. It's exactly the same at Manchester United, where the noise levels at Old Trafford for standard league games are exceptionally disappointing.
For two clubs who are similar in so many ways, it's no surprise that Barca and United's problems with stadium atmosphere share two crucial factors.
Firstly, a significant number of fans are "football tourists". Barcelona has become, according to one recent report, the most-visited city in Europe (overtaking Paris). And when you're staying in Barcelona, there are two things on the essential must-do list: 1. Look at Gaudi's buildings and 2. Go and watch Messi. Which is entirely fair, because both are touched by genius.
And although the city of Manchester is hardly a tourist hot-spot, Old Trafford has become a kind of Mecca for football fans: If you're in England (even London is only a three-hour train ride away) and Manchester United are playing, you simply must go and watch, even if you're not a Manchester United fan.
Walking around the Nou Camp or Old Trafford on a matchday, it's remarkable how many non-native faces and languages you can see and hear, with visitors from China, Japan and Korea the most common of all.
There's nothing wrong with this, of course ― it's a natural consequence of the clubs' status as global icons and they certainly do their best to milk the commercial potential of their international popularity through pre-season tours and so on ― but it does unavoidably exert a negative impact on the atmosphere, with many of the single-game tourists understandably not knowing the chants and songs, or sharing the same level of passion as die-hard regulars.
The other factor is success. Barca and United have won so many trophies in recent years, especially in their own domestic leagues, that fans have ― reasonably ― started to take victory for granted. Rather than dearly wishing for goals and trophies, they now expect them and the atmosphere, consequently, could be described as: "We expect you to entertain us" rather than "We will help you to win".
Again, there's nothing sinister in this and it's difficult to find a solution ― other than starting to lose, which probably isn't top of the priority list for either club.
It does mean, though, that if you're a Malaysian sports fan and you're planning a trip to Spain or England, you might want to revise your football-watching itinerary.
If you want to watch the best football, sure, go to the Nou Camp or Old Trafford. But if you want to sample the best atmosphere and experience what being a match-going football fan is really all about, try Espanyol or Stoke City. Ideally, of course, do both!
* This is the personal opinion of the columnist